Hi Tom, I was assuming a reasonably well balanced piano at the start. With a major reg for advanced pianist, the last job is always the una corda voicing, to get the widest colour change possible. Regards Roger At 09:24 AM 11/14/02 -0500, you wrote: >In a message dated 11/13/02 10:05:38 PM, roger.j@sasktel.net writes: > ><< If you have to make a choice between left and right hand, go with the >right >since that is where most tunes are played. > >> > >i would agree to the extent that half of the bass register is one string >anyway, and therefore regulating that register to the una corda would result >in only an octave full of notes that made a difference. That octave is often >critical, though, in achieving the effect of PP. > >In pianistic terms, the left hand often dictates the apparent dynamic level >of the music. To play PP (in a standard homophonic musical setting: RH >melody, LH accompaniment) requires the left hand to play as quietly as >possible, whereas the right hand is able to sing over the accompaniment, and >thus be much louder. A standard dynamic level of Mezzopiano in the RH and >Pianissimo in the LH would result in a perceived PP in the music. > >Now, keep that melody at the same dynamic level and increase the left hand >volume and you get a perceived dynamic level that is much louder than before. > > >It is the left hand that dictates the dynamic level. So having una corda in >the right hand only would really make things more difficult for the pianist >using the una corda pedal to achieve PP. (in homophonic settings) > >Tom Sivak > >P.S. >That was homophonic, (as in one voice supported by chords) not homophobic. >_______________________________________________ >pianotech list info: https://www.moypiano.com/resources/#archives
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC