Hi Barrie, Of the three 'wise' tuners one must be a Certified Tuning Examiner. A CTE must take courses, pass, administer examinations under supervision, and be approved by the PTG board. This procedure assures standard setup administration and scoring. A good quality, tunable, piano 6 foot or more is chosen then 3 to 6 hours or more can be spent tuning, measuring, retuning, remeasuring until a master tuning is achieved and stored. The aural master tuning HAS to be agreed to, in all particulars, by all three members of the committee before it is stored. Because of this time investment we like to use pianos in schools, churches or examiners homes. Sometimes it is very difficult to find a suitable environment and suitable piano. If there is a discrepancy in the examinee's tuning then all three examiners _must_ agree, by aural testing, that there is an error. If the test or the examiners cannot prove the error the points are given to the examinee. This is a time consuming test to administer (three hours or more per tuner) but it is absolutely objective. If a person can tune they pass. If the person cannot tune they fail. There are 8 parts to the test, pitch setting, temperament, middle, bass, treble, unisons, stability and I cannot remember the other off hand. A score of 80 on all 8 is passing. A score of 90 on all tests qualifies the person to begin CTE training if they have been a PTG member for 2 years or more (I think). Achieving 90 is far, far harder than achieving 80. All test scores are kept from the very beginning. If too few are passing one section of the test then the 'loading' factor can be adjusted to bring that test in line, statistically, with the others. Same for too many passing.
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC