List, Thank you for your continued discussion of this issue. When I changed the regulation to a deeper dip and longer blow (yes, 1 7/8"), I also put let-off closer than where it had been. I also like let-off to be as close as possible, but in my efforts to get the piano back to it's original "inviting" state, I also undid the close let-off ("generous" might be the wrong word, but definitely more than 1/16")so that adequate after-touch could be achieved without cranking the capstans even higher. I don't think at this point the aftertouch is excessive, merely what was necessary to make the pianist happy. I would invite your ideas of what an acceptable range of after-touch is - .045-.060? I believe what attracted the pianist to this piano (and the way it had been regulated) was "some form of finesse" (another way of saying "inviting") more than other considerations. I went into this knowing that I was trying to fix something that wasn't broken - a learning experience it has definitely turned out to be. My intent wasn't to >get into design issues, but just to observe from a practical point of >view that the likely cause of the annoying problems - repetition being >iffy and the jack hitting something, maybe the flange - was the excess >aftertouch, based on what Jeff reported. > If the action regulated well with .39 dip and, I assume, about 1 7/8 >blow, as Jeff stated (he didn't say how much blow), then it should >regulate reasonably well with .375 dip and 1 5/8 to 1 3/4 blow, at least >in my experience, with the caveat that aftertouch might be less than I'd >like and check distance might need to be tweaked on the far side. And if >that's what the customer wants, more power to him (he'll need it to get >the volume, but maybe he doesn't want volume so much as some form of >finesse). On the other hand, I find it hard to imagine a pianist wanting >greater than 1/16 letoff. > >Regards, >Fred Sturm >University of New Mexico > >Jon Page wrote: >> >> If you really want to start analyzing the key stroke, the location of the >> capstan >> on the key will determine where the jack will end up at the end of the key >> stroke >> with a given dip, hammer length & blow parameters. > > Jeff Stickney, RPT University of Montana jpage@selway.umt.edu
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC