Octave Tuning/ Harmonic vs. Melodic

Nichols nicho@zianet.com
Thu, 23 Sep 2004 19:26:30 -0600


At 05:39 PM 9/23/2004 +0100, you wrote:
>Yes Dean. That is correcto.
>
>To take things a step further.... to insure a very nice eveness its wise 
>to use several chromatic runs when checking through the final time. I find 
>that if you run chromatic triple, double and single octaves, and 12ths and 
>19ths and just listen for eveness, that any note that is slightly off, yet 
>seemingly ok by any given single test will stick out on one or more of 
>those chromatic runs. Adjust as necessary any that stick out so that they 
>fit nicely into all these chromatic runs.
>
>Cheers
>RicB

Totally agreed on the chromatic runs, Ric. I also run chromatic chords of 
an octave with the fifth in the middle. Sore thumbs stick out.
Now.. as you said..... to take things even further....
Don't forget when tuning octaves, especially through octaves 6 and 7, to 
check both harmonically and melodically. In other words, play the octave 
interval simultaneously, and then staggered. Works well with double 
octaves, also. The melodic octave will trick your ear into adding a bit 
more stretch, helping to counteract coupling effects and hyperactive attack 
pitch spikes from quarried hammers. A great "test" for the effect is to 
strike something like A5, and release. Tune A7 from memory, with at least a 
2 or 3 second break. Then play the double octave harmonically. Whew! Now... 
pull out the ETD. Shake your head, and move on................


Fun and games,
Guy


>Dean May wrote:
>
>>Ric wrote: A great aural test is to play the major 6th below the lowest note
>>of the 12th and compare that with that same 6th against the upper note.  Of
>>course the beat rates should be the same... but its one of the easiest tests
>>to hear clearly and quickly.
>>
>>
>>Ric,
>>
>>For clarity, in your example of D3-A4 as the 12th, are you saying compare
>>the F2-D3 beat ratio against F2-A4, and they should be the same?
>>
>>Thanks,
>>
>>Dean
>>
>
>_______________________________________________
>pianotech list info: https://www.moypiano.com/resources/#archives



This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC