At 09:38 PM 8/31/02 -0400, you wrote: >There are many different types of piano owners. There are some that are >true students of the piano, and play for their own enjoyment, and others, >who just want a piece of furniture to decorate their living room. >Therefore, the students naturally want theirs to be kept in tune, while >the others couldn't care less. I remember a client that called me for a >service call a few years ago, to fix a sticking key. When I got there, and >went over the piano, it was so badly out of tune that it hurt my ears. I >fixed the problem, and then asked her when was the last time she had her >piano tuned. She stated that not since she bought it 30 years ago, but >that it sounded good to her, and she has a good ear!! I collected my fee >for easing her sticking key, and left, knowing that she would not want to >pay for 3 or more pitch raisings to stabilize her piano. > >So, like beauty is all in the eyes of the beholder, sound is also in the >ears of the listener. When tuning, what may sound real good to you, might >not sound good to the client. It just seems that some people like the >sound of wild unisons, and when they are cleaned up they seem to think >that it just doesn't sound right anymore. This pertains to 95% of the >piano owners, and not the 5% of the ones that are serious I will demonstrate to a customer what in-tune and out-of-tune sounds like: I find a really ripe trichord and have the customer listen to that compared to the same note with 2 out of 3 strings muted. So far, everyone has heard the difference and agreed that the clean sound is better. There is then no question that the piano needs to be tuned. -Matt
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC