Carl, I have found it is almost impossible to refinish a spot in the lid or a flat surface without it being obvious. Therefore I do believe you were correct in telling the lady the entire top should be refinished and then there still could be a problem with the gloss matching. I am assuming it has been finished in lacquer. I'm sure there may be others who are better than I and can advise you on how to refinish a spot in a top without it being obvious. Tommy Black Decatur, Ala.
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC