tunelab vs RCT (and others)

Ron Koval drwoodwind@hotmail.com
Thu, 19 Apr 2001 13:19:18


Dave ? wrote:

>Hi!
>I've been tuning pianos aurally for about 2 years now, on a part-time basis 
>(I am a full-time band director).  I have been considering purchasing an 
>electronic tuner, but am not sure if it's worth the investment.  What I'm 
>wondering is:
>snip>

Hi Dave, and list

The short answer is, yes - all the current EDT's can do a good job.  The 
difference between the 'sampling' tuners and the ones that just have 
different curves built is something to consider.  I believe that it IS 
important to have a custom tuning for a particular instrument on that 
particular day.  That leads me to recommend RCT, Veritune, SAT, or Tunelab 
Pro.

Next, you need to decide if you want a dedicated machine, or something for a 
laptop, or pocket PC.  There are pros and cons to each.  There are differing 
learning curves with each as well.  Do you want something quick, and easy, 
or more user-definable?

As to the time-saving question.......Hmmm ... what part of the tuning is 
taking you so much time?  If you are taking a lot of time setting the 
temperament, then these will help a lot.  If you still need a lot of time to 
get the pins to stay put, then the EDT's may prove frustrating, because you 
can really SEE any slight drift to your tuning technique.

Good luck in your search, please post any additional questions!

Ron Koval

Chicagoland

_________________________________________________________________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com



This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC