Brian Trout wrote: > Hi Richard, > > You wrote: > > On the side... why do scaling programs not take into consideration the > string > > length from the tuning pin to the forward termination, but do take into > account > > the length behind the bridge ?? > > > I would venture to say that the length of wire behind the bridge is more > critical because the bridge is not stationary, but rather needs to move. If > the wire length is too short, it will indeed 'clamp' the movement of the > bridge. (That would be bad). Hmmm... I am begginning to wonder if this is so bad after all. It certainly would require other design considerations to be optimized for this configuation. But as to their affect to scales... Ok.. the bridge needs to move and the front termination point needs to be stable.. true enough.. but there is always going to be some leakage frontways, which means the front lengths contribute in some way or another. Tradition holds to ignore this in scaleing programs and formulas.. but what could be gained if these lengths were taken into consideration. I wonder for example what the real effect of the different lenghts due to the placement of tuning pins really is, and I have often wondered what would be the result if the length between the front termination and the deflection point was determined by the same criteria as backlengths are in scaleing programs, instead of this somewhat vague notion of "harmonic (or not) to the speaking length). Also... looking at this front duplex segment as how it contributes to total string inharmonicity instead of what frequencies it in itself is supposed to sing at (which never quite comes out right anyways). Just musing a bit.. but if anyone has any "in the know" info on this and has the time to jot it down.. well I am always gratefull for such.Perhaps at some point, I'll be > able to lay hands on those Journal articles as well. :-) > Grin... I too am looking very much forward to the Journal on CD > > Best wishes, The same to you my freind Richard Brekne I.C.P.T.G. N.P.T.F. Bergen, Norway > > > Brian Trout > Quarryville, PA > btrout@desupernet.net
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC