Old uprights - think twice

[Robert A. Anderson]

I used to recondition old uprights in my spare time - when I had nothing
more productive to do. I did about seven of them, I think, at about 2
years per piano. I could not have earned a living at it, but it was a
good learning experience. Each one presented different problems to
solve. I was able to experiment with adhesives, methods of repair,
materials, etc., etc. I service most of them today. I was lucky in that
they all worked out rather well. They are all in good repair and holding
their own against much younger pianos. Whenever I tune one, I look with
satisfaction at the extensive work I did. It was agonizing sometimes,
but for the most part I enjoyed the hours I spent. It is nice to be able
to see the results after a long time, and it is instructive to see what
worked well and what didn't.

I wouldn't know what to advise someone else. I have gradually done less
and less work on old uprights over the years, because I have become less
and less satisfied with the quality of work I am able to do on them for
a fee commensurate with their intrinsic value. I turn away upright work
today that was an important part of my income and education 20 years
ago. 

I think it's worth trying once. At least you could find out what's
involved and perhaps why not to do it. I am reminded that I rebuilt one
player action about 15 yers ago. I learned from the experience what I
needed to find out. In my case, I decided that I wouldn't pursue it. I
also learned a few things about player mechanisms.

I think it would be a rare technician who could make a decent living
doing a good job of upright rebuilding. But I wouldn't want to scare
anyone away from a profitable learning experience.

Merry Christmas, everyone.

Bob Anderson
Tucson, AZ