In a message dated 4/15/2000 9:13:01 PM, Bob A. wrote: <<"I took White's book to be my piano technician's Bible. I think quite a few others did, too. I guess I feel that I was misled.">> Bob; Please allow me to start with an excerpt from one of my replies to Ed Foote, i.e.; " Aren't 'most' of the writings slanted to a certain viewpoint?...............snip................. If all of the writers can't be "right" then how do we judge who not to follow?....... perhaps more importantly who to follow?" Braid White was 'one' of the authors I had in mind when I made this comment and even then 'most' that he has to say isn't wrong................indeed there is still quite a bit of disagreement on what 'exactly' the "Well Tempered Clavier" was written in/for. White was a passionate writer on those subjects that he cared deeply about, and like most of us his passion overode his objectivity at times. (maybe he was infected by Hemholtz :) The same same question I asked of Ed is one you need to find the answer to, i.e.; <<"......how do we judge who not to follow?....... perhaps more importantly who to follow?" >> Well Ed has already answered this in another context but the answer is still valid here. (paraphrased) *learn to tune the temperaments, try the ones you are interested in and then make up your mind about each of them by yourself*............. My only addition here is to be careful as to what you accept as 'gospel' from either camp or individual temperament(s) promoter be they ET or Historical or Alternative. Each of these has many valid viewpoints but none have the 'only' valid view. Don't feel "misled" by White he was sincere, passionate and wrong occasionaly but you are much the richer for having read his book. Jim Bryant (FL)
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC