I too favor fifths in the bass, and have tried Jim Coleman's suggestion of going with pure fifths down there. That is good for me as I tend to err sharp on short bass strings. For me the worst sounding interval in a console or spinet bass is the octave. As long as the octave + fifth (12th) sounds better, or at least not as bad, and the double octave (15th) sounds OK that's pretty much it. The tenths are only guide posts, useful as a double check for "errors", or possible errors. Well it does get the #5 partial into play. By listening to all of these intervals, the #5, 4,3, and 2 partials of the lower note are included in the tuning in the attempt to "balanced them out" Sure, it takes time to test and tweek these intervals but as one old pro said, "If you spend some time, a lot of these little pianos can sound OK." ---riconsoled > >kswafford@earthlink.net (Kent Swafford) writes: > > > ><< My personal preference when dealing with a > > large difference in inharmonicity at the tenor break is to give up on > > smooth beat rates in the 3rds in favor of smooth beat rates in the 4ths, > > 5ths, and octaves. >> > >
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC