Barrie, One element I forgot is that there is a tolerance range built into the scoring. Unisons are within .75 cents in the middle section. Stability ( dropping a specified weight a specified distance onto a key) is 1 cent. The section scoring is plus or minus 2 cents (?) to plus or minus 6 cents in the extremes. The better the master tuning the the wider the range for the examinee. This test was initially designed by Al Sanderson, Ph.D. and retired MIT electronics professor, consulting with MANY tuners and measuring LOTS of tunings and pianos. It has been evolving for close to 30 years and has been in place for some 15 years. Objective testing of tuning skills is the purpose which it does extremely well. Also CTEs must be retested every five years or so to reaffirm their hearing tuning and administration skills. Newton
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC