Tuning Steel pans

McNeilTom@aol.com McNeilTom@aol.com
Fri, 14 Jun 1996 17:30:15 -0400


Interesting article on "The Caribbean Steel Pan: Tuning and Mode Studies" by
Uwe J. Hansen, Thomas D. Rossing, Ellie Mannette, and Kaethe George in the
MRS (Materials Research Society) Bulletin, V. XX, No. 3, March 1995.  There
is a table showing  the inharmonicity of a particular note on a particular
pan, giving the following ratios of the partials to the fundamental.

1st partial (fundamental)     1
2nd                                   1.98
3                                       2.97
4                                       3.96
5                                       4.93

In other words, the partials fall below the pitches of a true harmonic
series, the opposite of what we're used to in pianos.  A sound pressure
spectrum is also given, showing a fairly smooth decrease in energy as the
partial series is ascended, rather like piano spectra.  There is also
appreciable "coupling" with other notes on the same pan, if they are tuned
harmonically (as opposed to equal-tempered intervals, for instance).  The
authors note that there is lots of variation in the behavior of various pans
since they are made of various grades and gauges of steel, with the heads
usually of different material than the skirts, and neither made with
matalurgically sophisticated nor highly controlled alloys.  The heads (which
start life as the bottoms of 55-gallon oil drums) are heat-treated over open
flame at about 600 degrees F.  After cooling, the tuning is done by
hammering, peining and punching the shapes of the various segments. Typically
three to eighteen notes are produced on one pan.

The article gives a bibliography of only three other references, one
unpublished, the other two in JASA, 82 (1987) p. S86.

Hope this helps!

-     -     Tom McNeil     -     -
Vermont Piano Restorations



This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC