[CAUT] Tone "contrast"; Was - The "new" S&S Hammers.

[Porritt, David]

Ric:

When you send out these flames it would help if you gave full names to
the targets.  You stated below "Secondly... it was not just a couple
three months back David did indeed 
air frustration......" There are several Davids on this list so some
indication of which one you meant would be helpful.  I know I have not
complained about the D+ so you must be referring to some other David
about some other problem with some other piano.  

Better yet, try a little harder not to send out these unnecessary
flames.

dp

David M. Porritt, RPT
dporritt at smu.edu


-----Original Message-----
From: caut-bounces at ptg.org [mailto:caut-bounces at ptg.org] On Behalf Of
Richard Brekne
Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2007 4:57 AM
To: caut at ptg.org
Subject: [CAUT] Tone "contrast"; Was - The "new" S&S Hammers.

I dont think anyone mentioned Rochester...... Where does all this 
jumping to conclusions about what other people are talking about come 
from ? Why is there so much defensive and very liberal reading into 
others words meanings that are not necessarily there ?

When Ron first asks the specific question about his D++.... for the 
first it has nothing to do with  Steinway D.  Let us be clear on that 
matter. Any claim to the contrary is a simple falsehood IMVHO.  
Secondly... it was not just a couple three months back David did indeed 
air frustration over a unspecified number of pianists who reacted 
negatively to it on what I personally would agree (based on Davids 
descriptions at the time) were grounds that bordered on the realm of 
prejudice. 

You simply can not make a piano that will please all the people all the 
time. And like it or not... for whatever reasons , justified or not... 
the only instrument that has ever come even close is the Steinway... 
complete with front and back duplex, without Baldwins vertical 
hitchpins... with compression soundboards... etc etc ad absurdum.  I am 
indeed sorry if anyone finds that fact (and it is a bald bold undeniable

fact) uncomfortable.... but hey.... thats life.

RicB


    Jim,
    I'd like the short list of those "pretty" pianos at Rochester
    that didn't do it for you, please. A straightforward naming of
    names, so we who brought pianos will know where we stand and
    where and how we failed. Specifics, if you please, for our
    education. How else will we learn?

    David,
    Has anyone at SMU complained about the narrow palette of
    colors available from the D+ I did for you folks? If so, why
    haven't I heard about it?

    I'd really appreciate some specificity here from both of you,
    so those of us on the block from Rochester (and elsewhere)
    will have a clue what the bitch is, to better evaluate our
    methods and general philosophies toward rebuilding.

    Thanks,
    Ron N