[CAUT] Re: Plate Substitution

James Ellis claviers@nxs.net
Sun, 23 Jan 2005 10:18:16 -0500


John Schaldack suggested that it's the screws through the plate and into
the pinblock and the dowels at the ends that keep the block from moving -
not the block's fit against the plate frange.  Sorry, John, that's
incorrect.  Those screws may keep the block from rolling away from the
plate up at the flange, but there is no way they will keep it from slipping
with that 40,000+ pounds pulling against it.  If tuning-pin bushings are
used, they will limit that slippage some, but if they are not, as I believe
is the case here, a good fit against the plate flange is an absolute must.
Without it, you can count on having all sorts of stability problems.  A
good fit against the plate flange has been the accepted standard for well
over a century.

John also mentioned common hitch pins on the older Baldwins, and
"Accu-just" roll pins on the newer ones.  That's correct.  Also, I should
mention that the newer Baldwin plates - SD-10, etc. -  do not mount against
the rim in the same way as the older ones, and if a plate substitution were
to have been made, that might present a problem unless the rebuilder really
understood the newer system - which is patented, but that patent has now
expired.

Jim Ellis 


This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC