tough enough

[PAULREVENKOJONES]

Personally, I think the exam is brilliant in its conception and application.

What isn't brilliant is a mind-set that says that 80% is good enough and that that is all one needs to achieve. Too much "no tuner left behind" mentality both in the Guild and among its aspiring members. Too much studying to the test rather than studying piano technology as a whole, the concepts underlying what we do, and general diagnostic skills that make us truly technicians. 

Paul

"If you want to know the truth, stop having opinions" (Chinese fortune cookie)


In a message dated 08/10/07 21:06:24 Central Daylight Time, custos3 at comcast.net writes:
At 06:11 PM 8/10/2007, Don <pianotuna at accesscomm.ca> 
 wrote: 

>Hi Chuck, 
> 
>It is my understanding that no one has yet received a perfect score on the 
>tuning exam. Imho that makes it "tough enough". 

Don Tuna, 

You don't judge an exam by how hard it is to achieve perfection. You 
judge it by how easy it is to pass. And an 80% tuning isn't anything 
to crow about. Neither are unisons which are off by the maximum 
tolerance that still gets you the point. People with a pair of 
functioning ears in their heads who learned how to use them wouldn't 
be happy with either. Which is why many tuners feel that the exam is 
not " tough enough". 

Israel Stein 
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: https://www.moypiano.com/ptg/pianotech.php/attachments/20070811/89331b56/attachment.html