On 18-jan-05, at 23:32, Richard Brekne wrote: > Grin.... > > Couldnt resist Andre... the answer is as always.... it depends on > which one was <<better>> > > rb > >> I have posed this question before : >> >> If you had the choice : you can get a brand new Steinway D and you >> can get a hundred year old Steinway D... >> What would be your choice? >> >> André Oorebeek >> >> > > _______________________________________________ > pianotech list info: https://www.moypiano.com/resources/#archives > > I know you Ricardo, Tough cookie when it comes to sound boards. I think we all agree that there is definitely a difference between an old board and a brand new one. If Dale Erwin replace his board in the D he has been working on, then he must have had a reason. We (Grand Piano) too replace old boards and the new ones are always better. I want to know why and, although my professional life is all about restoring old beauties, I still like the sound of a new Steinway (or any other name) better than an old one. My intuition tells me that it has to do with the cellular structure and with fatigue of the wood in general. Re-ribbing is not always a good answer. I think we all have our preferences so taste is actually not an issue here. Maybe the sound board kings on this list could help answer this question? friendly greetings from André Oorebeek Vita Dura Est
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC