I've been following this thread with amusement and interest. How many of you have seen the hand process for making hammers? You could take a 50 pound sheet of felt and "skive" it to the dimensions to use it in a "12 pound cull" and have truly nice hammers, albeit, rather small in dimensional size. On the other hand, you could take a 12 pound sheet of felt and "Skive" it to the dimensions to be used in a "20 pound cull" and have nice hammers, albeit humongous dimensionally. Either would be ok for the tone desired. The big problem, as I see it, is how the felt is treated. Is it cold pressed or hot pressed. Is it pressed with 50 tons of pressure or is it pressed with 15 tons of pressure? And then there is: how long were the hammers left in the culls to get their "set", etc. The variables are endless. Those hammer makers that make the same consistent hammers, time after time after time, are aware of the variables and make an effort to control them. Those hammer makers that don't have the consistency are not paying attention to ALL of the variables ALL of the time. Hence, we have such a litany of opinions of what is a good hammer. The best advise I ever got for this dilemma was: "Find a hammer/maker that does the best job for you. Get used to working with that hammer. And you will be able to get whatever tone desired. In other words, if you keep bouncing back and forth from one hammer to another, you simply are spinning your wheels, IMO. A lot has to do with the seller; how good are they at supplying, shipping and extra help, when needed. All these things go into making the hammers of your choice. I had a very good technician extol the virtues of Steinway hammers. I tried them and found them to be inconsistent and downright unworkable, FOR ME. He gets good results. I do not. Hence, I use something else. When it comes to voicing, I have added to my knowledge, over the years, to be able to COPE with most hammers. This knowledge also tells me which hammers I do not want to use on a regular basis. I hate the voicing process and will do darned near anything to avoid it. But that's another story, for another day. Best Regards, Joe Garrett, RPT, (Oregon) Been There, Didn't Like It, So I'm Here To Stay! [G}
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC