Try putting a couple of drops of 50% -50% Hide glue and water, (distilled is best), on the back catch stem area and the area where the stem goes into the butt. Your putting a piece of felt between the check and the catch may simply reduce the energy going through the stem. Masks the area shock absorbsion, but gives a false idea where the noise is coming from. Anyway, give it a few minutes and then try the note again. Should tell you where the noise is coming from. If there's still the noise, then I would suspect loose catcher wires in the catcher head or in the wippen. There is also the possibility that it has some thin backcheck felt that is too hard. On pianos around the 70's, some manufacturers started using this weird stuff and it is noisy. Best Regards, Joe Garrett, RPT, (Oregon) Been There, Didn't Like It, So I'm Here To Stay! [G}
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC