graphite and Protec

David Ilvedson ilvey@sbcglobal.net
Thu, 21 Nov 2002 19:00:46 -0800


Well, Jim, I just got to disagree in a way.  Nothing wrong with spray graphite on the reps/jack but it don't work as well as micro-fine teflon.  I never put any kind of graphite on knuckles...Wim wasn't talking about grease graphite...

David I.


>Avery, et al.........
> ANY product that leaves a greasy/moist feeling on the knuckle should NOT be
>used.
> There is a vast difference between graphite grease and stick graphite and if
>you mean "grease" it should be included in the ID. Spray teflon (alcohol
>base)as well as powdered teflon work very well on knuckles and so does
>'stick' graphite. To condemn the 'proper' use of "graphite" as somehow
>politically or technically incorrect is just wrong...period :-)
> There are many viable applications in the action for graphite use and to
>lubricate knuckles is one of those as is its use as a burnishing on jack tops
>and balancier rails.
> If graphite use is overdone then it gives just as bad results as using other
>inappropiate "lubricants"................. A new set of knuckles with a
>'lite' swiping of graphite (stick form) as well as a powdering with teflon
>will feel better and last longer than either of these two alone.............
>But what do I know? :-)
>Jim Bryant (FL)
>_______________________________________________
>pianotech list info: https://www.moypiano.com/resources/#archives


This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC