--- Joseph Garrett <joegarrett@earthlink.net> wrote: > Bob, > Are you a piano technician? I ask this, because some > of your comments are > simply false. "Victorian Pitch", as you put it, is > 1/2 tone flat. This is > simply untrue. If you had done some study on the > subject, as I have, you > would know that "Victorian Pitch", first of all, is > stupid classification, > as there were many pitches during the "Victorian > Period". To put it simply > this is why we now have a "Standard" pitch. However, > in the interim, what > most considered "Victorian Pitch", or on this side > of the "Pond", > "International Pitch", was A=435cps, (or C=517cps), > this "pitch" is 20% > lower than A=440cps, NOT 100% flat, ("1/2 tone"), as > you state! As for > Chopin hearing his music a 1/2 tone flat, that is > pure BS. It depended on > which city he was in as to what pitch he was > subjected to. And even in the > same city, there were various pitches for each > particular venue. Do your > homework and then joust with me. <G> > Respectfully, > Joe Garrett, RPT, (Oregon) Hello Joe, You sign your emails 'respectfully' but I'm not so sure that you mean it. Firstly, yes, I am a piano technician, nearer retirement than the beginning. I Tune for Andrew Lloyd Webber and his musicals, I spend a lot of time at Phantom of the Opera and have done for 15 years. I am also tuner to the Henry Wood Trust. They have premises for 85 young musicians who come from all over the world, the concert artistes of tomorrow, and I look after their pianos and work with them. I also tune for many top musicians, concert artists and venues - so I don't want you to think I spend my time rolling around London tuning birdcage pianos! Of course I know that there were several pitches in use in Victorian times - it is just easier to say Victorian pitch than list them, they were lower than today's pitch and you know it - but I notice you have ignored the important part of my argument - is Chopin's music less beautiful in those pitches (take your pick) than what you call the proper pitch - See your previous email. Personally, I feel that if past composers came back and heard their music performed in the glorious technicolour of equal temperament A440 on powerful modern concert grands they might consider it brash and vulgar, especially if they had been used to the lighter tones of wooden frame pianos. Incidentally, I have read all the major biographies of Chopin including the definitive Arthur Hedley biography, so I actually feel I do know something about the subject. He favoured Pleyel pianos. But, Joe I will always bow to your superior knowledge. I feel that if someone can turn Englands worst pianos into something decent after they have passed their hundredth birthday (when they were nothing special when new) then they deserve to be listened to. By the way, I never did see your promised birdcage post on the purpose of the overdamper action. Did you post it at Christmas, when I was away or is it still to come? Yours, Bob Wilson. London. p.s. You might like to tell them in Vienna that we have a standard pitch now - they are using A446 there! and a recent competition in Germany stipulated A443 ! __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Send FREE video emails in Yahoo! Mail! http://promo.yahoo.com/videomail/
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC