Darn, I did it again. It should be 1854, not 1954: I wrote: > So, does Jorgensen contradict himself? In 1977 he says that ET existed > universally after 1954. In 1991 he says that nobody could have tuned ET > before 1900. I don't think he contradicts himself, really. I think in his > later book he uses a stricter standard for ET. It's like when people say > you can't tune ET accurately using Braide White's method, and many today > aren't tuning ET when they think they are. But I don't think it's fair to > say that because of that, ET didn't exist at all until it could be tuned > to pass the RPT exams. It seems that ET existed, in concept and in an > attempt at practice, in the last part of the 19th century. But it wouldn't > have satisfied today's tougher standards for an accurate ET tuning. > > Charles
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC