soundboards improving with age? or what else?

[Richard Brekne]

---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment


Delwin D Fandrich wrot

>
> No, Richard. You show us, you refer us to, you quote, you--in any other
> sense--document any study, anywhere, from any source, that scientifically
> demonstrats that there ARE significant changes in the way sound and wood
> inter-relate as a result of wood aging, or varnishing for that matter. When
> you can do this you will lend some credibility to the claims that this
> relationship exists. Until you, or others making these claims, can do this
> you will reside in exactly the same place as those who declare other
> unsubstantiated ideas to be fact.

That last sentence is precisely my point Del... and exactly where I find you in
this matter.

No Del... I am not the one declaring that we have an answer to this
question...one way or the  other... quite the opposite I am the one who says we
don't know. And you are mistaken when you draw the conclusion that I believe
that age does have an effect. What my position is, as I have stated at least 5
times now is that this is not something that is known. You are the one with the
position,  and the burden of proof is upon you. Just as much as is it upon those
who declare the aging is indeed a factor. Same thing really applies to the
varnish issue in violins.

And really Del, I don't need to be a piano designer to recognize these issues
are debated by significant numbers of folks sporting all kinds of neat titles.
If  there was a conclusive proof one way or the other...this simply wouldn't be
the case.

>
> No offence, Richard, but really, if you want to add any credibility to these
> claims you need to come with some kind of proof--or at least some credible
> theory to explain them--or find some evidence to substantiate them or you
> need to stop blowing your magic smoke.

Its not me whose blowing smoke Del. I have claimed nothing more then that this
is an unknown. So again... you who make a claim must show the proof. This would
be the case whether the position represented is the one you take or the one
taken by the magic varnish side. All I hear on the issue of aging is a lot of
claims on both sides, and thetas what I have reacted against and that's all I
have said anything about. So I would appreciate it if you would cease and desist
with the attachment of meanings or words to me that I do not stand for, nor have
never stated.

>
> > And for the last time... nobody is comparing Violins directly to pianos...
> the
> > Violin examples are used in conjunction with wood ageing... not with
> differing
> > stress situations. Until you prove that ageing of wood per se has no
> > significance... then it will continue to be natural to use such examples.
>
> Sure seemed like it to me. Until you can prove that the aging of wood per se
> has any significance in the performance of the piano soundboard I will
> continue to reject such comparisons.

That, my esteemed piano designer... is because you have not bothered reading
what I really have been saying. And for the umpteenth millionth time dear Del...
I have never said that aging of wood DOES effect the performance of sound boards
significantly. What I HAVE said is that if you are going to deny that it
does...especially when you label such beliefs as superstitious nonsense, then
you have to be able to prove your standpoint. Until you do then your standpoint
is in the end just as believable as the magic juice story, or any of the rest.


>
> > Science is science... treat it that way.
>
> As you say, science is science. Treat it that way.

exactly... prove what you hypothesize, or recognize it for the hypothesis it is.

>
> Regards,
>
> Del

As far as the books you recommend.. Benade, at least I have... and I dont recall
ever seeing the issue of wood ageing relating to sounding boards dealt with in
that book...... tho I will take another look tommorrow.

But you who obviously assume I am so unread might want to check out the
following tittles... for some other perspectives.

Buchanan, G. 1990 Making Stringed Instruments
Abbot, J. 1987 Cited in, Bucur, V. 1995. The Acoustics of Wood.
Boyden, D.D. 1961. The Violin, in, Baines. A. 1961. Musical Instruments through
the Ages.


Bucur, I might add cites the following  factors relative to changes in wood as
it ages

Chemical and physical changes over time with fluctuations of temperature and
humidity and effects due to the playing process,  mainly the results of
vibrations and static loading.


--
Richard Brekne
RPT, N.P.T.F.
Bergen, Norway
mailto:rbrekne@broadpark.no


---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: https://www.moypiano.com/ptg/pianotech.php/attachments/b5/cc/d2/a6/attachment.htm

---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment--