"Howard S. Rosen" wrote: > *****I re-read my letter and it did sound as though I was rebuking Richard. > Sorry, Richard and thanks Keith for tactfully scolding me on that issue. Let > me just say, without any personal attacks, that my opinion on this matter > is simply that 'natural beats' is a meaningless expression. At best,it is > the same thing as the beats we hear resulting from coincidental > partials.****** Glad to have read these words... was sad to think maybe I was in for another er.... slagsmål.... grin.. Have enjoyed reading your previous posts on a wide variety of threads. Sorry for my part on firing back so quickly and perhaps harshly... As far as whether or not the term "natural beats" is meaningless.... well perhaps you are right... but then perhaps not... we dont know that for sure yet.... or at least I havent seen any real hard data / facts whathaveyou to prove it one way or the other yet. And hey.... if it turns out Virgil is indeed on about something but just lacks the ability to explain it clearly... we should indeed want to know about it... or what ? Shake hands ??? <smile> > Howard S. Rosen, RPT > 7262 Angel Falls Ct. > Boynton Beach, Fl 33437 > > hsrosen@gate.net -- Richard Brekne RPT, N.P.T.F. Bergen, Norway mailto:Richard.Brekne@grieg.uib.no
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC