I wrote: << "In the keys found in the middle of the circle of fifths, there is a less dramatic difference in the tempering, allowing certain "alignments" of the intervals to produce triads with a lot of the beating working together." And Doug writes: >>Is this beating that is working together the rhythmic harmoniousness? >> Greetings, Yes, this is what I thought Owen meant by his original statement. The beat rates are proportional to each other in certain triads. The "Rhythmic harmoniousness" isn't a term I would have used, as most of these rates are beyond what I would have thought of as "rhythm". I have just finished a Broadwood 7' grand restringing and action set-up, and last night put Paul Bailey's '92 well temperament on it. This is a very clean sounding tuning, and while it hasn't the contrast of say a Kirnberger, there are numerous places in the temperament in which the M3 and m3 share a proportional rate, (at least, the way I have it does). These triads have a clarity, yet at the same time, a lot of "activity", as Margo says. Can an 8 year old temperament be saddled with the "historic" designation, or is it simply a temperament, like all the others........? Regards, Ed Foote RPT
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC