I would appreciate the advise of PTG members on the proper way to restore old and antique musicial instruments. Does the PTG believe that all old musicial instruments should be restored 100% originial as they were made in the factory? Or is it proper to "alter" the originial design of a old instrument? I ask this because in adition to tuning pianos, I restore old reed (pump) organs. The Reed Organ Society has a monthly magazine and a internet list which I belong. I recently posted that I tune reed organs to A-440 (most were tuned to around A-435). Not one reed organ technician thought it was proper at all to tune them to A-440, but they said they should be left at their originial pitch. I got all kinds of "hate" mail from the purists for daring to alter the design of these valuable instruments from their originial design. I mentioned I sometimes do a few other alterations to make them a better instrument. Well, I have been sick over this since because I have no desire to harm the historic value of any old antique. Please tell me what some of you technicians feel about this. If reed organs should not be altered or changed in any way, wouldn't this apply to all anitique musicial instruments as well as pipe organs, old radios, old wind up phonographs and even furniture? The purists believe that everything should stay the same on restoring old antiques. What is the general thinking on this today and where do we draw the line. Thanks Jim Turner
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC