At 02:09 PM 1/30/98 -0500, you wrote: >List >Allow me to cast my vote for ET...whether for jazz or classic. > >just a lowbrow!! > >Ralph Martin > Allow me to cast my vote for ET, except in very particular circumstances, by people who really know what they are doing. The rest of us can experiment on our own pianos, playing our own music of whatever type, and developing our own tastes. Disclosure and permission, ALWAYS, _especially_ for performing pianists. Anything else is forcing them to improvise, without warning, in front of an audience. If they have not already adjusted to the temperament in the past, several weeks of practicing with it might hardly be sufficient for them to change their musical interpretation and feel comfortable. Who are we to inflict our notions on them? If it is perfectly easy for them to adjust to a "mild" whatever, it is probably because the "ht" was so close to "et" as to make no never mind. In all this bandwidth, I've seen no mention of the tolerances normal in performing and listening to music. "How do string players manage to play with the tempered scale of a piano?" Nothing simpler. We listen with our hearts instead of with a micrometer. Also, we listen to melodic rather than harmonic intonation. In successive rather than simultaneous intervals, a structural sense of size matters more than beats. (Mental picture: two fine, generous major seconds, like pillars, added together into a third, below a small semitone, which leads strongly to the note above; add them together, and you will have a clear perfect fourth. Fourths, fifths, octaves, all untempered: supports perfectly aligned and dovetailed, like in a timber frame building.) Good string intonation is a matter of a vocal inflection, almost. One or two cent differences are so trivial in actual playing as to be completely unnoticed. With clean, warm unisons and musically-sized and uniform octaves, the 1 cent differences in temperament are totally indistinguishable, IMHO, not just for musicians, but for _everybody_, when actually listening to real music. (No, Mr. Bremmer, I am not calling you a liar.) As a string player, I float on a Pythagorean ocean 41 years deep, and just thirds give me a pain. just a highbrow! Susan Susan Kline P.O. Box 1651 Philomath, OR 97370 skline@proaxis.com "By using your intelligence, you can sometimes make your problems twice as complicated." -- Ashleigh Brilliant
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC