Barrie writes: >In the interests of an authentic sound, should you not be tuning your >piano to C 505.7 as this was the pitch used by Broadwoods at the time >Beethoven received his piano in 1818. Greetings, Barrie's letter points up a common misconception with our projects. We are not intending to create an "authentic" sound. That is not possible today, ( in the literal sense). There are no "authentic" audiences to be had, since we have grown up in an age devoid of the key character that Mozart and Beethoven accepted as normal, also, most of the "authentic" instruments available are, by necessity, extrapolations. Even the Cristofori piano has a replaced soundboard in it, doesn't it? Our intention is to intensify the performance experience. Whereas the instruments we use are relative newcomers to the world of music, (modern hi tension pianos are only about 150 years old), the effects of the musical scale predate history. It is the presentation of these effects that I consider to be at the heart of Well temperament. So far, the reservations about using WT on modern pianos seem to mainly arise from those that have not heard them. I am unable to address these concerns, as they are, of necessity, based on conjecture and interpretation of historical beliefs, not on the physical sounds that I am proposing to be more emotionally affective. In blind trials with WT accompaniment for singers, the first time a singer went through their piece, there was some confusion. The second time through, with the newness gone, the unanimous decision was that it was easier to sing in key, when the piano was taken out of equal temperament. Listening to acappella vocal solos, with the SAT turned on, seems to indicate that when the piano is silent, the singer soon turns to something other than ET. I have called this "floating Pythagorean" for want of a better description. The simple fact is, that I can respect a persons distaste with our sound far more than I can accept a rejection from one who has not listened to it. The former is a valid musical decision, as legitimate as anything I possess, while the latter is only a reactionary response to the unknown. Use of ET requires very little musical decision, use of WT requires much. How much tempering is too much? That is a personal question, but to find an answer requires listening. That is all I ask. Regards, Ed Foote
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC