Richard asks a lot of questions. I will not answer all but give some reasons for it. I am not sure when the practice began but know that it works. You ask if it is necessary. I feel it is the cause for at least 20% OR More of the voicing problems we have as tuners. If a hammer excites two of the three strings before the third and hits the third softer and not solid it excites the string in a different mannor. The partials don't ring the same and you can have a "wang".(official tech talk) Don't level by bending the string... I use a tool that is sold by Schaff affectionately called the Mannino hook. It was recomended to me by LeRoy at Yamaha. It is a great tool. I massage the string up more than I would yank.(more official tech verbage) Do not reeeef on the string to level just massage it up. You must have shaped the hammers perfect before even starting this process for good result. Block the hammer and then pluck the strings and see if any ring...level then check again. If you have a piano in tune and strings that appear level after checking and the shape of hammers are good then and only then do you start to "voice" the hammers. To many of us grab the needles and start to jab when the problem is likely not found in the hammer at all. My two cents, Ed Tomlinson
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC