Ah, now you're bringing another factor, voice, into the matter of hammer selection. It's certainly worthy of consideration, and in the process, complicates things somewhat. The weight of the hammer-- measured in grams--is of comnsiderable importance to the touch of the piano. If we're restoring an instrument where we want to pre- serve the original touch, measuring and matching up the weights of both the original hammers and the replacements becomes of primary importance. And it's not just a matter of weighing and matching up the first and last hammer of each section, it a matter of weighing and matching each hammmr. All eight-eight. Now you want to add to that matter of the "voice" of the hammer. Different moldings-- walnut, mahogany, birch, etc--have different weights, and as the density of different felts vary, so too will their individual weights. So the wieght of a particular hammer depends upon BOTH the type of wood used for the molding and the density of its felt. From a touch standpoint, it really doesn't matter whether the hammer's weight is the result of a heavier molding and a less dense felt, or a lighter molding and a denser felt, but the such a selection can have a big impact on the voice of a particular hammer. In other words, it might be the correct weight, but the voice is all wrong. Kind of like your making that Bechstein sound like a Yamaha! Therefore, not only the weight of the hammer is important, but how that weight is achieved in terms of molding-weight/felt density must be considered, too. Les Smith lessmith@buffnet.net On Fri, 21 Mar 1997, Barrie Heaton wrote: > Yes, your on the right tracks. Les and Horace had described density to > you very well. May I add though, the customers requrements should be > taken in to account. I misinterpretered a customers request on his > Bechstine he said it had lost its "umph" my neighbour has a lot of > "umph" His neighbour had a brand new Yamaha which I tune. Which is > very bright and lovely bass. So I assumed he wanted a bright piano. > Boy was I mistaken it took me six months and a loot of visits to tone > those hard hammers down. What he meant by umph he wanted a nicer bass > but he still wanted his Bechstein sound which is a soft mellow treble > compared with a Yamaha. > > Some of the Bechstein Grands start at gage 13 at the top so a dense > hammer is not necessary to produce a quality sound. That's why > personally on grands around the 1920 and down. I tend to go for re- > covering rather than replacing, it is a bit like buying a set of pre- > hung hammers the re-coverer matches the original felt so all you'll have > to do is replace the rollers and re-centrer the hammers plus they are a > little bit cheaper. > > Hope this is of some help. > > Regards, > > Barrie. > > > > In article <09151041200001@DEBCOM.BE>, Peter Kestens > <KESTENS.P@Debcom.be> writes > >PETER KESTENS > >Het Muziekinstrumentenatelier > >BELGIUM > >KESTENS.P@Debcom.be > > To Barrie Heaton, > > > >Could the density of the felt being of any importancy? The higher it is, > >the more it weights? > > > > > > > > > > -- > > Barrie Heaton | Be Environmentally Friendly > URL: http://www.airtime.co.uk/forte/piano.htm | To Your Neighbour > The UK PIano Page | > pgp key on request | HAVE YOUR PIANO TUNED > >
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC