atodd-thanks for clarifying to Kuang about tuning flat and string breakage, etc. I tried to explain in my reply to this thread. Greg Torres, Technician Niceville, Fla tunapiana@aol.com << Subj: Re: String breakage Date: 97-04-10 12:12:16 EDT From: atodd@UH.EDU (Avery Todd) Kuang, This is something you should *seriously* consider changing. I don't know for a fact about that practice causing more broken strings, but it isn't necessary at all. You introduce a lot of tuning stability problems (which I believe you mentioned having in one of your earlier posts) and you add a lot of excessive wear on the tuning pin hole, which will eventually contribute to loose pin problems. The tuning flat thread was primarily referring to a very slight "bump" on the pin to break loose any strings that were rusted at the pressure points. I can see no advantage at all of going a half step flat before pulling the string back up. But I can see a *lot* of disadvantages of doing so. Just my opinion. Thanks. Avery >Ever since I began to tune flat before going up in pitch, more and more >strings break from tuning, _not_ playing. >I broke at least 3 strings while I was tuning last month. >The reason why so many string broke is because I always tune at least a >half note flat (100 cents) before going up in pitch (almost always). SNIP > >Kuang Wang
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC