Hey Allen, That's a toughy, even for more experienced techs although they don't don't deal with it as much in later careers as they can arrord to pick and choose the gravy jobs. I recently had a client whose piano was purchased in 1948 and had not been tuned since date of purchase.......for real!! Pitch was down about a fourth...strings rusty.....a candidate for "tuning, as is" I explained the whole story of pitch raise.....breaking strings.....the whole nine yards and guess what? She wanted it brought to A440....no matter the cost or how many strings went......she was "gonna start takin' lessins and wawntud it raht". My heart sank!!!!! The thought ran through my head to back out while I had the chance... I predicted a very high breakage rate. Raised the pitch gradually.....note to note, then chromatically, over a couple of visits and "never broke a string" and brought it to A440.....no problem. I was stunned!!!! Just this week I raised the pitch 15 cents on a "quality" grand piano about ten years old and broke two treble strings.......they looked practicaly new......go figure. Certain manufacturers used higher than normal scale tensions which contribute to excess breakage. Being familiar with those can help in evaluating whether to raise old strings or not. Everybody seems to have a "secret formula to aid with pitch raises.......lubricants........backing off tension then raising. I'm not aware of a scientific meathod for evaluating a needed pitch raise......just time and experience.........Dale P.S. Are you sure you're goin' to A440??
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC