Hi Folks. We (the UiB music conservatory) just took delivery of a brand new Hamburg D to replace a 4 year old Yamaha CF III that will now become the number 2 instrument on our concert stage. We have a small concert hall and its a great place to compare the sounds of these two brands. Have to say right off that I have enjoyed the CF III quite a bit these past 4 years and have become very familiar with its character. But it has always had a difference that marks it as a Yamaha. A certain roundness to its tone that is rather hard to describe. It has all kinds of brilliance when you want it... but of a very different sort then a Steinway. Anyways.. the new instrument unpacked and a couple pianists eager to try it out.... I get to sit back and get a feel for the sound of this new addition to our instrument park. Holy moly.... what a beautiful sound. I mean as nice as the Yamaha is... this D had everything the Yamaha lacked and more. I've heard side by side comparisons in big halls and been impressed with the carrying power of Steinways, but this Yamaha is no slouch and has been through such a comparison and compared more then favorably with an aging D... which now has been re-hammered and would fair far better but thats a different story. But in an intimate hall there are far more detailed characteristics that come immediately forward in such a comparison. That ofte times criticized Steinway Duplex functioning at its best contributes to the treble and high diskant so nicely its just incredible. The Yamaha simply does not do this, tho it has a similar front duplex arrangement... they just dont get that same sound. I personally believe it has to do with the capo profile but thats another matter as well. And the bass !!! Jesus Di Cristi !! You play these big huge loud chords with low bass tones booming through and you dont loose the individual tones in a mesh of overtones... There is this tubular tinge to the solidity of the bass tones that just eats the Yamaha bass right up. And again... this is a particularly good Yamaha we are talking about. Ok... I am the first to underline that when using words like "better" and "best" when describing subjective things like piano tone preferences that one is indeed totally in the world of the subjective... so I'd like to do that right now. This all says as much about what I like in piano sound as anything else. But I was indeed blown away. On the side of all this, we decided to try out an Essex upright... 123. I was anxious... and a bit nervous having heard so much negative about these. Of course its brand new and time will tell... but initial reaction was quite pleasant surprise. Very nice sound and touch. We'll see what the first year of use will bring. Cheers, and Happy Summer to one and all RicB
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC