A 440 Hz Standard

James Ellis claviers@nxs.net
Tue, 13 Apr 2004 09:22:44 -0400


All of you who responded to my original "A 440 Hz Standard" post have
illustrated the point I was trying to make even better than I had hoped
for.  I thank you, one and all.

One of my 100-year-old (1904) Chickerings still has the original marking on
the plate - "INTERNATIONAL PITCH, A 435".  It appears that the "I'm better
than you are" mind-set resulting in the ever-climbing pitch has been around
for a long time.  We thought we settled it when the "International
Standard" was set at A=440 Hz, but it's obvious, we had not.  The same
nonsense persists.

There was a special meeting at the Kansas City PTG Convention in 1985, with
people from several foreign countries attending, when we tried to re-affirm
the standard.  We tried, but here we are again.  Your various posts have
illustrated perfectly the fact that everyone would be better off if we
would all stick to the same standard.  But I don't have any false hopes,
and I fully expect history to keep repeating itself, and the confusion to
continue.

On the other hand.  Does anyone think it's worth another try?  Like what we
tried to do in Kansas City in 1985?  I would vote YES.  What about you?

Sincerely, Jim Ellis



This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC