As long as people are discussing hardening agents and dilutions, I'd like to place a query I think I made a good while ago: what lacquer? Could be nitrocellulose or acrylic (those are the two I'm aware of - are there others?), the first used mostly for furniture (wood), latter for autos (metal). Nitro gets pretty brittle when completely cured (which takes a while), while acrylic retains some flexibility. I've heard from various people that they prefer one or the other, from others that there is no difference. Wonder if I might elicit additional comments in that regard. On a similar note, I wonder if there is any essential difference between acrylic lacquer and "keytop" solution, other than the vehicle/solvent ("keytop" is typically pure acrylic in pure acetone, while acrylic lacquer thinner has other solvents designed to ritard drying among other effects. And I don't know what other solids might be involved). I wonder if adding lacquer thinner to acetone, or substituting lacquer thinner for acetone altogether, in making "keytop," would change the results. Slower drying/curing might affect where how much solid ended up, and possibly its final characteristics. Guess I ought to experiment, huh? But maybe somebody else has already. My experience with "keytop" has been mostly pretty favorable, but maybe because I apply to shoulders and don't let it soak into the crown. I'm not sure I am able to hear a difference between one hardening agent and another, unless it is applied directly to the crown. (There, the difference between lacquer, sanding sealer, and "keytop" is fairly pronounced). On another, related topic, I like to use the hypo-oiler to apply hammer dope. A hint for keeping the stuff from evaporating between uses: insert a short piece of harpsichord wire (somewhere in the .010 to .015" range) in the needle when not in use. I found a diameter that fit pretty precisely. Put a tiny kink at the end so it won't fall in, then put the plastic cover over it (the one that comes with the bottle) and evaporation is close to eliminated. If you don't have access to harpsichord wire, a straight pin or needle can substitute. Fred Sturm University of New Mexico A440A@aol.com wrote: > > Horace writes: > <<The newer instruments will need hardening. Simple. The amount is going to > vary with each situation. In some cases, 4:1 (lacquer thinner:lacquer) is > the right thing to use. In others, perhaps thinner combinations, or use of > lacquer sanding sealer or shellac is appropriate or more reasonable. >> > > Greetings, > I think we could profitably discuss this dilution thing. I have used > various strengths with various results, but would hope that a communal-cyber > reach for consensus could give us all a broader perspective. (OK, that is a > verbose way of saying, "let's talk about the solution", but blame it on a > long day and a little Scotch).
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC