Jon, On Sun, 3 Dec 2000, Jon Page wrote: > Roger, > The Damper upstop rail slapping on the belly rail is a good candidate. > > Hardened guide rail felt is another possibility along with the damper head > itself being a bit loose on the wire. I think step 6 would eliminate this possibility. > > Hmmmmmm... > Thanks, John > Jon Page > > At 11:50 PM 12/02/2000 -0600, you wrote: > >Hi John, > > Guess we could be grasping at straws, but a couple of other > >things to try. > > > >Is the damper guide rail secure to the belly rail? > > > >If the board is flat in this area, that can cause some thud like tones. > >Measure the bearing with a compound gauge, and check the board for some > >curvature. > > > >If the glue joint on the inner rim or belly rail is loose similar > >result. > >Take an artist pallet knife, (.010" thick) and see if you can find any > >looseness between the board and liner. > > > >Just some thought's > >Roger > > > > > >John D. Chapman wrote: > > > > > > Remember THUD? > > > Here is the history. I had not seen this piano until last month. > > > While tuning I noticed that notes 50, 51, 52, and 53 (top four notes in > > > agraff section, just below the treble break) had an unpleasant > > > knock/slap sound, the same percussive knock which is in the background of > > > all piano tone, but in notes 50-53 it dominates the tone. These are the > > > four notes between A440 and the treble break. The orchestra conductor > > > asked me if I had noticed those four notes, as did the pianist, so I knew > > > it wasn't just my imagination. I have checked it out both upstage and back > > > stage (wood floors), and back at the dealership (concrete floor). > > > Here is what we have done so far: > > > 1. checked hammers for loose glue joint, flange pinning, and screw > > > tightness, > > > 2. visually checked the action frame joints between notes #53 & #54, > > > 3. checked the wippens for sufficient felt at the front to keep the > > > jack from slamming into the rep lever, > > > 4. checked key frame bedding, front, back, and glides, with and without > > > damper pedal, and with and without shift pedal, > > > 5. pressed down the back key frame with a long screwdriver to see if it > > > was slapping up against the dag, > > > 6. played notes with dampers held all the way up by hand and by pedal, > > > 7. moved the action in and out to see if the tone improved, > > > 8. switched some hammers from the octave below to see if it could be the > > > hammers, > > > 9. switched some whippins from the octave below to see if it coulb be the > > > whippins, > > > 10. seated the strings, > > > 11. applied firm pressure on the bridge cap at the end of the section to > > > see if there was a loose glue joint between cap and bridge body, > > > 12. checked for clearance between the bridge and the plate, > > > 13. checked for loose ribs, > > > 14. checked for clearance between nose and bell bolts and soundboard, > > > 15. checked that the bell bolt nut which was one turn past finger tight, > > > 16. checked for foreign object lodged between soundboard and frame, and > > > between soundboard and plate, > > > 17. tightened the end screws of the diagonal plate bar, which could be > > > turned another half turn to snug, > > > 18. checked key leads and underlever leads, > > > 19. checked the key bed with a straightedge front to back. I found that > > > the board just beyond the board on which the balance rail glides rest was > > > high. Chalked it where it passes under the front to back board of the key > > > frame which is just under notes 50-53 and found that is was just barely > > > touching. Sanded key frame there until there was adequate clearance. > > > Playing the note by pushing up on the whippin from underneath with my > > > finger without moving the key still produces the THUD, so I guess that > > > eliminates the keyframe anyway. > > > > > > None of this has changed the THUD. > > > What have I missed? > > > Why these four consecutive notes with no sign of the problem above or > > > below them? > > > > > > John Chapman RPT > > > Wake Forest University > > > Winston-Salem NC >
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC