Dear Allen and list: I am new to this list and will try to keep my comments brief and polite. We have 34 new Steinways that are about two years old and they all have terrible V-bar noises. Although after many hours of playing time some of problems do disappear it is still no excuse for the sloppy workmanship which continues to plague the stringing department at S@S. I think the V-bar itself is not so much the problem as is the application of the wire. The Kelly company does an excellent job of the V-bar profile and it should just need some clean up when it gets to Steinway. Where Kelly fails miserably is in the front duplex bars which are left with epoxy and paint on the bearing surfaces and again sloppy attention to detail. Just compare a Hamburg plate to a Kelly and you will see what I mean. The front duplex bars should have as much attention as the V-bar with emphasis on draft angles and clean, smooth bearing surfaces. This is not all Kelly's fault since Steinway should take it upon themselves to correct these problems as needed as plates arrive to them. Allen, in my opinion, the noise problems can be mostly eliminated by careful workmanship. Steinway needs to improve in several areas for this to happen. First, the bridge notching should be more accurate. There are many times when the bridge cut is ahead of the pin line and in the V-bar sections this becomes a huge problem for noise. Secondly, when rendering the wire under the V-bar the unison should be aligned with just enough tension to hold it in place then very carefully checked for alignment again as the wire begins to make an impression in the bar while pulling up the tension. The current method at Steinway is to pull up the tension without to much concern for alignment because the action regulators have the prerogative to jack the wire from side to side as the clock gets closer to quitting time. I have technically represented Steinway dealers for years in every possible scenerio and still have the highest regard for their company and product but the time it is taking to correct no-brainer deficienies is appalling. So much for brief and polite.
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC